Últimos posts
After Architecture as Spectacle
Nobody has formally certified the death of “architecture as spectacle”. But it can’t be denied that in recent years the number of(...)
“Learning from the Existing City”: An Urban Climate Refuge Network for Barcelona
Entre las propuestas ganadoras del concurso World Dataviz Challenge 2019 del Ayuntamiento(...)
Designing: Both Directions at Once
Es frecuente que singulares cosas cotidianas nos ayuden a reflexionar en qué consiste el proyecto de arquitectura. La música contenida en(...)
To bim or not to bim
A while ago we were reflecting on the role architecture plays in the virtual world. It looks as if trends are not only found in the worlds(...)
Tema - Formación
The First Year of a PhD in Architecture
El primer año de doctorado es un viaje de autodescubrimiento y exploración. Es un lugar lleno de animales silvestres que, como uno mismo,(...)
Choose Your Own Adventure: The Strange Case of FDPs in Architecture
If I may, I’d like to compare the success of those little paperbacks with that of the(...)
Classroom Experiences: In Favour of a Global History of Architecture 2
On the first day of class we presented the syllabus for the History of Architecture(...)
Tema - Investigación
Attitudes Towards the Inexorable Reality of Indexed Journals
Indexed journals and the need to publish in them as a pre-requisite for being able to defend my doctoral thesis are the news of the day in(...)
The Virtual Public Square
In our previous article we talked about the work being done to “viralise” architecture, and how other disciplines have had no(...)
Reversible Building Design: Design for Sustainable Change
Desarrollo del concepto de Diseño de Edificios Reversibles, el cual forma parte de la estrategia de aplicación de la economía circular a(...)
Julia Ayuso
Por
Publicado el 26.04.2019 en , Visitas Fecha de publicación 3 minutos

Is it Worth Doing a PhD in Architecture?

Tokyo

A PhD, or doctorate, corresponds to the third cycle of official university studies and leads to the acquisition of skills and competences needed for high quality scientific research. It’s the highest post-graduate qualification that can be obtained and gives its holders the right to be referred to as “Doctor”. The Spanish Royal Academy defines “doctorate” as “full, complete knowledge of a subject”.

The posts in this blog express different opinions regarding the PhD in Architecture. Some affirm that its research dimension is purely instrumental, justifiable as preparation for writing the thesis but reflecting no real interest in furthering knowledge of a given subject. Others say a doctorate has no impact on an architect’s professional activity outside of teaching, unless the specialisation accredited by the qualification is being showcased on the international labour market. Still others question the rigour of scientific publications – a sine qua non prerequisite for defending a doctoral thesis – on the grounds that they’re often based on reviews by other doctors who aren’t necessarily experts in the fields studied by other researchers. In this respect, however, there are also people like Carlos Camara, for whom the important thing is the expertise in scientific methodology that a doctor can contribute to research in general.

In view of such differing opinions,, and having just finished my own six-year doctoral research programme at the ETSA (University School of Architecture) in Madrid, including a two-year pre-doctoral placement at a university in Japan,  I would like to submit my own thoughts on the issue. They’re summed up in 3 main ideas:

  1. A PhD requires optimism.  Despite all the times you’ll be told that a PhD is worthless in Spain, that the future of a doctor in Architecture is far from secure, or that no company is going  to be interested in the qualification, and even though you may sometimes find it difficult, I think it’s important to remember that the PhD is something rewarding that allows you to study what you really love in depth. It’s an experience that will enrich you both professionally and personally.
  2. A PhD is useful.  In my case, one of the key reasons for choosing the subject of my thesis was the knowledge that when it was finished I’d be able to deliver a practical tool for promoting good architecture.
  3. In a PhD you don’t only learn about a specific subject, or pick up transversal research skills.  I like to say that a PhD is a personal journey: a path leading to a distant destination, that I set out on without really knowing why and which ended up giving me what I didn’t even know I was looking for.

Are you considering doing a PhD? Are you currently doing your research, or have you finished it already? Do you have a different point of view? Going back to the question in the title of this post: for me, doing a PhD is definitely worth it.  And very much so.

Text translate by Andrew V. Taylor
Autora:
(Elche, 1983) Como resultado de mi trabajo de investigación, hago labores de diseño y consultoría de espacios de trabajo centrados en las personas, que contribuyen a la mejora de su salud, bienestar y productividad. Soy Doctora Arquitecta y Project Manager especialista en cuantificar el beneficio económico que supone para las empresas la implementación de estrategias de diseño centrado en las personas, y actualmente dirijo People Lab en CBRE. No siempre quise ser arquitecta. Cuando era una niña pensaba que tal vez sería exploradora, o científica, o inventora. He viajado por todo el mundo para ver, tocar y sentir la arquitectura que me emociona. He vivido varios años en Japón, y lo que más me gusta de este país es su amor por lo bello y lo sutil (y el matcha).

Deja un comentario

Tu correo no se va a publicar.

CAPTCHA

*

Últimos posts
After Architecture as Spectacle
Nobody has formally certified the death of “architecture as spectacle”. But it can’t be denied that in recent years the number of(...)
“Learning from the Existing City”: An Urban Climate Refuge Network for Barcelona
Entre las propuestas ganadoras del concurso World Dataviz Challenge 2019 del Ayuntamiento(...)
Designing: Both Directions at Once
Es frecuente que singulares cosas cotidianas nos ayuden a reflexionar en qué consiste el proyecto de arquitectura. La música contenida en(...)
To bim or not to bim
A while ago we were reflecting on the role architecture plays in the virtual world. It looks as if trends are not only found in the worlds(...)